04 — College · Religious Studies

THE CHURCH OF THE
ABSOLUTE BEGINNER

The Religious Studies Department. Not the belief — the rite. No one arrives. No one is left behind.

The Statement of the Church

When asked who was greatest in the kingdom of heaven, Jesus placed a child among his disciples.

The lesson was not ignorance, but humility. Not the abandonment of knowledge, but the abandonment of superiority.

The Church of the Absolute Beginner begins there: with the understanding that learning does not confer greatness, certainty is not wisdom, and no one possesses the final answer.

We study religion, belief, doubt, and the human search for meaning without requiring anyone to arrive at the same destination.

To be an absolute beginner is not to have learned nothing. It is to recognize that there is always more to learn.

No one arrives. No one is left behind.

Matthew 18:1–4

I — The medium

What is done in the rite

A department of the College is a medium, not a subject. The English Department holds what is done in language; the Art Department what is done in the image; Media Studies what is done on the screen; Cartography the map; Psychology the case file. This department holds what is done in the rite — the act repeated until it no longer needs a reason.

Not the belief. The rite. The Mythology Department already holds the story, and a story can be believed from a chair. A rite has to be done — stood for, said aloud, eaten, kept on a particular day — and it does not ask first whether you believe it. Althusser has Pascal give the order in one line: Kneel down, move your lips in prayer, and you will believe.1 The scandal is the direction of the arrow. The practice comes first, and the conviction is what it produces. That is this project's thesis, stated three centuries early, in a room this project did not build.

The discipline's oldest courtesy is to study a religion without ruling on it. Ninian Smart called this methodological agnosticism:2 whether the thing is true is set to one side — not answered, not dismissed, set aside — so that what is done in its name can be looked at. It is usually taught as a professional restraint, a thing the scholar does. The Church takes it as a description of the scholar. The question is set aside because the person holding it is in no position to settle it, and neither is anyone else in the room.

A department that studied the rite only from a chair would have learned the wrong half. So this one keeps a rite of its own, small enough to be watched while it runs: a church with a statement, a hymn, and an order for saying it.

II — The word

Absolute, as opposed to false

The name is borrowed from the language schools, which sort their arrivals before the first class. An absolute beginner has never studied the language. A false beginner has — a year at school, a phrasebook, a grandmother — and tests as though they had not. The schools keep the two apart because the second is the harder to teach: what is half-known is in the way.

The Church takes the first term and means by it something the schools do not. On the questions this department holds — what is there, what is owed, what happens — it has found nobody who studied to the end, so its placement test has one result. That is not a finding that nothing was learned. The learning is real, and it did not change the placement.

III — The company

Others who began here

The position is not new, and the Church does not claim to have found it. Each of the following was asked, in its own room, to rank the learned, and declined.

  • Matthew 18:1–4

    The disciples ask who is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven. The answer is a child, set in the midst of them, and then the sentence that undoes the question: Whosoever therefore shall humble himself as this little child, the same is greatest in the kingdom of heaven.3 A ranking was requested. What came back was a rank that can only be held by declining it.

  • Socrates · Athens, 399 BCE

    Told that an oracle had found no one wiser, he goes looking for someone who is, and reports the only advantage he could find in himself: he does not suppose he knows what he does not know.4

  • The Rule of St Benedict · sixth century

    The document that organised Western monasticism for the better part of fifteen centuries ends by describing itself as a little rule written for beginners.5 Seventy-two chapters of instruction, and the seventy-third says that this was the start.

  • Nicholas of Cusa · 1440

    De docta ignorantia — on learned ignorance.6 The title is the argument: the ignorance is the thing that has to be learned, and it takes an education to reach it.

  • Shunryu Suzuki · California, 1970

    In the beginner's mind there are many possibilities; in the expert's mind there are few.7

Five rooms, and they do not say the same thing. A Galilean teacher, an Athenian defendant, an Italian abbot, a German cardinal and a Japanese priest in California disagree about nearly everything this department studies, including whether there is anyone to pray to. The Church does not hold that they were secretly agreeing. That would be the superiority it gave up, come back wearing a syllabus.

IV — The hymn

Four lines, each in two halves

  1. No one's an angel but no one's a sinner
  2. No one's a loser but no one's a winner
  3. It's never summer but it's never winter
  4. Nothing moves forward but nothing is hindered

Every line takes a pair of verdicts and hands both back unsigned. But look at the kind of word being refused. Angel, sinner, loser, winner: each is a person made out of an act. Somebody lost, once, at something, and the noun keeps them there. The English Department describes the general move — what somebody did becomes what somebody is — and the Psychology Department finds it in every file. The hymn is the same operation run backwards. It does not say that nothing is lost or that no harm is done. It says no one is a loser and no one is a sinner: the act stands, and the person is let out of it.

The third line does the same to the calendar. There is no season in which this is finally in bloom, and none in which it is over.

The last line is the doctrine. Nothing moves forward refuses the staircase — the stages, levels and degrees by which a tradition tells its members how far along they are, and so who is ahead of whom. But nothing is hindered refuses the conclusion a tired reader draws from that, which is that there is no use starting. Take the staircase away and the floor is still there.

V — The rite

The hymn, said

A hymn that is only read has been studied from a chair. This is the order for saying it, and it is the whole of the Church's practice: five lines, about a minute, the same every time.

The page gives the first half of each line. You give the second, which is set in italic. Type it, or say it aloud and tell the page that you have.

The page checks the words where it can see them and takes your word where it cannot. It has no way to ask whether you meant them. No church ever had one either.

Nothing is kept. There is no count of how many times this has been done, by you or by anyone, and when it is finished there is nothing to show for it.

  1. No one's an angel but no one's a sinner
  2. No one's a loser but no one's a winner
  3. It's never summer but it's never winter
  4. Nothing moves forward but nothing is hindered
  5. No one arrives. No one is left behind.

What was just done, and what it did, is the subject of Lesson One.

VI — The curriculum

Lesson One

The curriculum is made of first lessons. There is no Lesson Two — not because the material runs out, but because the numbering would be a claim about the student.

  • Lesson One · held

    The Rite

    What is done before it is believed, and what the doing produces. Where the department starts, and where it expects to be found.

  • Lesson One

    The Creed

    A sentence said in unison. What saying it together does that believing it separately does not.

  • Lesson One

    Doubt

    Kept by every tradition, usually under another name. Studied here as a practice, not as the failure of one.

  • Lesson One

    Conversion

    The day a person's account of their own past is rewritten, and the earlier life becomes the part before.

  • Lesson One

    Heresy

    From the Greek for a choice. The word a tradition keeps for the moment somebody made one.

  • Lesson One

    The Rite Not Called One

    The oath, the anthem, the commencement, the all-hands meeting. What a secular room repeats until it no longer needs a reason.

What the department currently holds is two rooms: this one, and the first of the six. The other five have no page. They are named because a syllabus is a promise that can be checked, and they will be built in no particular order, each of them first.

VII — The bounds

What the Church does not claim

It is not a religion
And it does not compete with one. A member of any may attend, and so may a member of none. Nobody is asked which.
It has no clergy
Somebody holds the door. That is a job, not a rank.
It keeps no roll
The College keeps one, by charter. This is the one room in the building where being counted is not on offer.
It takes no collection
The press that houses it asks for support on a page of its own. Nothing here depends on the answer.
It does not say all answers are equal
No one possesses the final answer is a claim about possession. Some answers are better than others. None is finished.
It does not say knowledge is suspect
The learned know more. What the Church declines is the next step, from knows more to is greater.
It was made up
By us, recently, and it says so at the door. It makes no claim about how any other church began. That is among the things it does not know.
VIII — The standing

One disagreement with its own College

The College confers a standing on those who finish. Its Charter makes a Professor of Meaning of anyone who completes a year's study and answers the examination. This room holds that no one arrives.

Both are kept in one building on purpose. Finishing a piece of work is not reaching the end of a subject, and a candidate who completes a study in this department is a Professor of Meaning and an absolute beginner on the same day. The Church's position is that this describes every professor, including the ones the other colleges make.

Notes & sources

The Apparatus

Research notes — v1.1 · 2026-11-10

  1. Louis Althusser, “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses (Notes towards an Investigation),” in Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays, trans. Ben Brewster (Monthly Review Press, 1971). Althusser introduces the line as what Pascal says “more or less”: it is his paraphrase of the Pensées, not a quotation from them.
  2. Ninian Smart, The Science of Religion and the Sociology of Knowledge: Some Methodological Questions (Princeton University Press, 1973). The term answers Peter Berger's “methodological atheism” in The Sacred Canopy (Doubleday, 1967).
  3. Matthew 18:1–4, Authorized (King James) Version.
  4. Plato, Apology 21a–d. Paraphrased, not quoted.
  5. The Rule of St Benedict, ch. 73. Paraphrased, not quoted; see RB 1980: The Rule of St. Benedict in English, ed. Timothy Fry (Liturgical Press, 1981).
  6. Nicholas of Cusa, De docta ignorantia (1440).
  7. Shunryu Suzuki, Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind (Weatherhill, 1970), Prologue.

← The College of Meaning Production